AHV: -6.8% per year early
Legal AHV age is 65 for men, transitioning from 64 to 65 for women. You can leave 1, 2 or 3 years early — each early year cuts your AHV pension by 6.8% for life. At 62, your pension is cut 13.6%. At 60 (the most extreme case, with medical waiver), -20%. On a CHF 2,500/month pension, the yearly loss is CHF 4,080 and lifelong. By age 85, cumulative loss exceeds CHF 100,000.
Pillar 2: capital vs annuity, plus the cut
At retirement, you choose: withdraw the BVG capital in one shot (preferential tax ~5-12%, separate from income) or keep an annuity. The annuity equals your capital × conversion rate (4.8-6.8% by fund). With early retirement at 60, capital is typically -20% (5 fewer years of contributions + interest), and the conversion rate may be cut 0.1-0.3 points per early year. The gap between staying to 65 vs leaving at 60 on an average fund: CHF 600-1,000 lost monthly pension for life.
Withdrawal tax: staggering required
BVG, 3a and vested-benefits withdrawals are taxed separately from income, at a federal + cantonal progressive rate totaling 5-15%. Crucial strategy: never combine all withdrawals in the same year — you'd hit the top bracket. Stagger: 3a in year N (CHF 100,000), vested benefits in N+2 (CHF 150,000), BVG at exit. In Geneva, staggering saves CHF 15-25,000 in tax vs withdrawing it all the same year. Check your 3a is split across 3 foundations for 3 staggered withdrawals.
Filling gaps before exit
If you plan to leave at 60, identify your AHV gaps (years without full contributions) and 2nd-pillar gaps (unbought-back years). Filling these via BVG buy-ins in the last 5-10 years has dual benefit: immediate income-tax cut (BVG buy-ins fully deductible) and increased retirement capital. Caveat: any BVG buy-in must stay invested 3+ years before withdrawal, else tax clawback. Planning at age 50-55 is therefore essential to truly leave at 60.
Polia recommendation: the real need
Before any technical math, answer the real question: how much do you actually spend per month today? For a typical Geneva retired couple, average need is CHF 8,000-10,000/month (mortgage paid, no debt). AHV+BVG+3a must cover that. If the sum is CHF 7,500/month, leaving at 60 cuts to CHF 5,500/month — unsustainable. If it's CHF 11,000/month, leaving at 60 cuts to CHF 8,500/month — livable but tight. Polia always recommends a 30-year projection (life expectancy) with 1.5-2% inflation. A "clean" early retirement typically needs CHF 1.5-2M of financial wealth outside real estate.